Two claimed proofs of the Riemann hypothesis: one with Claude, one human-only
An Anthropic researcher posted a Lean proof he says settles the Riemann hypothesis, and another mathematician posted a human-only draft. Neither is fully confirmed yet.
One researcher says he solved a 167-year-old maths problem with AI help, and another says he solved it alone. Checks are still going, and nobody has fully confirmed it yet.
Hype check
Louder than it deserves. The real change is smaller.
Our editorial opinion, based on the sources below. How we score
Your call: hype or real?
Real = it will matter in daily use. Hype = louder than it is. One vote, and it can’t be changed.
Our view and readers’ views are opinions, not statements of fact about a product.
Why it matters
The Riemann hypothesis is one of maths' best-known problems. If the result holds, it is a landmark for AI in mathematics.
Watch: it may be a big day for maths, but wait for the explanation and confirmation.
The details
- Levent Alpöge, who works at Anthropic, says he reached a Lean-compilable proof of the Riemann hypothesis (posed in 1859) while working with Claude.
- Participants in a Lean chat, including MIT mathematician Andrew Sutherland, say the proof compiles. TechCrunch reports independent sources have checked it.
- Alpöge has not yet released an explanation humans can read, and has promised one. So the mathematical content is not yet understood.
- Separately, Stanford postdoc Alessandro Masullo posted a draft proof with no AI, announced by Ravi Vakil, president of the American Mathematical Society, after about 12 years of work.
- Masullo's draft has not been written in Lean, so it is too early to judge.
Receipts
One trusted outlet reports it. Not confirmed yet. Open the sources and check us.
Written with the help of AI tools and checked against the sources above. How we work
See a mistake? Tell us and we’ll fix it.